Table of Contents
What Do You Mean By Federalism?
Federalism is a system of government in which power is equally distributed between several different entities. And similarly, every entity is given the power to share control over another geographic region as another entity. So, you can say that federalism is a system in the United States where laws can be passed by a local government, the state government, or the national government.
System of Federalism
This system of federalism also stops one solitary body from being able to control over every aspect of governing over the population. It also refers to the system in which some tiered laws and systems can be confusing for the other geographic regions where some laws may conflict. Take an example of marijuana legislation that occurred in the US. If we talk about recreational marijuana, it may be legal in some states but illegal at the national level.
Local Law Versus National Law
Even though some local law enforcement may not arrest, because they think that the actions by state laws are fine. While on the other hand, we are going to discuss that national laws may dictate otherwise and allow a national law enforcement officer to conduct an arrest anyways.
In this article, we are going to elaborate on the most cited pros and cons of federalism.
Pros of Federalism
First of all, let’s have a look at some pros of federalism.
Sense of Local Patriotism
People in federalism feel closed themselves to their communities. No doubt that there is always a level of national pride, but local patriotism is the first level of loyalty and faithfulness to which an individual will ever encounter. Federalism also impetus this local loyalty by allowing communities to create laws and regulations that give advantage to them.
Because governments these days are usually at the local level, people know friends or neighbours or members of the family who are active in creating policies, procedures, or even laws. There is no doubt that most of the elected positions from schools or colleges and from hospitals to the city council and mayor are local officers. As there is open access to the government, it also encourages involvement because serving these days is easy to do.
Separates the Powers of Government
Imagine if the President of the US has to eliminate all other branches of government and there will be no congress, and even there will be no supreme court. What will happen next in this case? Because there is the separation of powers and freedom is still ensured until the end of the state. In this way, the local government serves as independent of the state government, and checks and balances permit independence.
As we know that there are tired levels of rules and regulations, but the level of bureaucracy that exists within federalism is lower than that of the government structures. In other words, diverse populations have different needs that need to be met. While the government tries to understand those needs and process is difficult. So, if you allow local or regional populations to have this power, the safety and security of a community can be met in a better way.
Evidence of Success or Failure
As regional and local communities have their laws and regulations, so government structures view it as the evidence of success or failure. It can also be looked upon as efforts to determine if they could be used in other geographic regions. Moreover, welfare reform in the US originated from the efforts made by regulation, especially in Wisconsin. For example, many of the environmental population policies originated from California.
Cons of Federalism
Now it’s time to switch towards the cons of federalism. Few cons are listed below:
Because you know that laws vary in each geographic region and people who travel or more to slightly different locations find themselves violating the law, on the other hand, recreational marijuana may be legal in Colorado, but if you take a legally purchased product, then it implies you are violating local law. It also means that sometimes you are even breaking the national rules on marijuana with a purchase. It also makes it difficult for people to decide if their actions are either right or wrong as a citizen.
Read More: College Essay About Pros and Cons of Botox
Impetus Government and Creates a Wealthy Gap
It is true to some extent that these days no one of us wants to take responsibility for failed policies in the structure of government. Now everyone blames everyone, and this creates a gridlock between the various agencies. Nothing will be done in this situation as everyone blames others for their actions. Moreover, each group feels that their moral or ethical position is clear.
Serious efforts are being made to maintain socioeconomic differences at local levels. And the national government is advised to fill in the gaps which exist in a society with historically mixed levels of success.
Causes Uncertainty and Used for Leverage
Wildfire is seen in the United States throughout each summer and who is responsible for taking care of this issue. On the other hand, if a hurricane blasts the eastern seaboard and causes extensive damage and even in some cases flooding and homelessness and who is responsible for responding? Because the government is tired and no one is sure about how to react in such situations. If we don’t respond at the time, then it may lead us to create delays in service.
Let’s consider that the government wants to bring changes in the healthcare laws for their employers, but a handful of healthy regions don’t desire any changes. To bring changes, the national governments could offer additional funding or resources to the hold out regional governments. The system of federalism encourages dissent that can be used for leverage to grab more resources.
Above listed pros and cons of federalism shows that this type of political system is created to ensure freedom of expression. This concept also refers to the meaning that no one can have all the power, and in other words, the population can’t be overrun by the government.